Monday, 12 October 2020

The Universal Destination of Goods: Pope Francis, Pope John Paul II and Rerum Novarum

I have recently had reason to study Pope Leo XIII's Encyclical Letter Rerum Novarum. The sense as one reads Leo XIII's account of the right to private property, of which he gives an extensive defence in terms of natural law, the family and in its nature as the fruit of a persons labour (nn.4-9, 11-13), is that it is the right to private ownership of property that comes first followed by the teaching on the demands of the universal destination of goods (n.22).

The balance in the account of the seventh commandment in the Catechism of the Catholic Church (nn.2402-2406) appears more strongly to put the universal destination of goods first, and the right to private ownership of property as second to it.

The right to private property, acquired by work or received from others by inheritance or gift, does not do away with the original gift of the earth to the whole of mankind. The universal destination of goods remains primordial, even if the promotion of the common good requires respect for the right to private property and its exercise.

Pope Francis cites Pope John Paul II's Encyclical Letter Laborem Exercens on exactly this point. John Paul II asserts that the right to private property is subordinated to the universal destination of goods in the context of a particular discussion of ownership of the means of industrial production (n.14), though Pope Francis cites a later reference (n.19) to this principle in John Paul's account of the part played by a worker's wage in allowing access to a share in the universal destination of goods.

In a section of the Encyclical Letter Fratelli Tutti entitled "Re-envisioning the social role of property", Pope Francis writes:

118. The world exists for everyone, because all of us were born with the same dignity. Differences of colour, religion, talent, place of birth or residence, and so many others, cannot be used to justify the privileges of some over the rights of all. As a community, we have an obligation to ensure that every person lives with dignity and has sufficient opportunities for his or her integral development.

119. In the first Christian centuries, a number of thinkers developed a universal vision in their reflections on the common destination of created goods.[91] This led them to realize that if one person lacks what is necessary to live with dignity, it is because another person is detaining it. Saint John Chrysostom summarizes it in this way: “Not to share our wealth with the poor is to rob them and take away their livelihood. The riches we possess are not our own, but theirs as well”.[92] In the words of Saint Gregory the Great, “When we provide the needy with their basic needs, we are giving them what belongs to them, not to us”.[93]

120. Once more, I would like to echo a statement of Saint John Paul II whose forcefulness has perhaps been insufficiently recognized: “God gave the earth to the whole human race for the sustenance of all its members, without excluding or favouring anyone”.[94] For my part, I would observe that “the Christian tradition has never recognized the right to private property as absolute or inviolable, and has stressed the social purpose of all forms of private property”.[95] The principle of the common use of created goods is the “first principle of the whole ethical and social order”;[96] it is a natural and inherent right that takes priority over others.[97] All other rights having to do with the goods necessary for the integral fulfilment of persons, including that of private property or any other type of property, should – in the words of Saint Paul VI – “in no way hinder [this right], but should actively facilitate its implementation”.[98] The right to private property can only be considered a secondary natural right, derived from the principle of the universal destination of created goods. This has concrete consequences that ought to be reflected in the workings of society. Yet it often happens that secondary rights displace primary and overriding rights, in practice making them irrelevant.

 The three Popes - Leo XIII, John Paul II and Francis - each address different historical contexts: the rise of socialism (but read carefully how this term is to be understood) in the case of Leo XIII, the question of ownership in largely industrialized societies in the case of John Paul II and the selfishness of largely post-industrial societies in the case of Francis. Pope Francis teaching can be seen to be in absolute continuity with that of his predecessors in the See of St Peter, and with a particular application to the circumstances of his time.

Sunday, 11 October 2020

Universal Fraternity: Pope Francis and St Francis

 Pope Francis takes, it appears to me, a very significant step when he writes, in the first paragraph of his Encyclical Letter Fratelli Tutti:

"FRATELLI TUTTI". With these words, Saint Francis of Assisi addressed his brothers and sisters and proposed to them a way of life marked by the flavour of the Gospel. Of the counsels Francis offered, I would like to select the one in which he calls for a love that transcends the barriers of geography and distance, and declares blessed all those who love their brother “as much when he is far away from him as when he is with him”. In his simple and direct way, Saint Francis expressed the essence of a fraternal openness that allows us to acknowledge, appreciate and love each person, regardless of physical proximity, regardless of where he or she was born or lives.

Whilst it is not clear when and under what circumstances the Admonitions, to which Pope Francis refers in this paragraph, were composed, they would appear to have been addressed to gatherings or chapters of the early followers of St Francis. St Francis would appear to have attached great importance to them, wishing them to be written down exactly as he had delivered them.

The first audience of these words, then, are the brothers gathered around St Francis himself; and then, with their preservation in the Franciscan tradition, members of the Franciscan order reaching down to our own day. The intention is that they should give an account of the style of life expected of the brothers. So, for example, the praise of the brother who loves a brother both when they are far and near might have a reference to the Franciscan who has travelled or is away from his community.

Pope Francis, however, has St Francis address the Admonitions to "his brothers and sisters". There is a textual justification for this, in that the text of many of the individual admonitions refer in a generic way to the blessings of the "servant who ..." (much in the style of the Beatitudes). While the context of their composition suggests a direction immediately to the brothers engaged in the Franciscan life, the text taken apart from this context can be given a wider audience, that is, an audience of all those who would live a Christian life, both men and women. 

This generalization of the applicability of a life according to a religious rule to all Christians reminds me of an observation made by Louis Bouyer in the Preface to his book The Meaning of the Monastic Life.

The purpose of this book is primarily to point out to monks that their vocation in the Church is not, and never has been a special vocation. The vocation of the monk is, but is no more than, the vocation of the baptized man. But it is the vocation of the baptized man carried, I would say, to the farthest limits of its irresistible demands. All men who have put on Christ have heard the call to seek God. The monk is one for whom this call has become so urgent that there can be no question of postponing his response to it ... But this is tantamount to saying that this book is equally for every Christian ...

The last sentence of the paragraph extends the Franciscan charism of fraternity to apply it to each and every person, be they Christian or not. The movement of the idea of fraternity referenced in the paragraph is therefore from a specific charism associated with St Francis towards a wider experience applicable for all who would live a Christian life and, eventually, to suggest an applicability of the idea of fraternity to each and every person, be they Christian or not.

It argues for the extension of a Christian charism of fraternity in the wider world. To suggest otherwise is to misrepresent the inspiration of Pope Francis as expressed in this paragraph.

Sunday, 14 October 2018

Canonisations

I am delighted that Archbishop Oscar Romero and Pope Paul VI are now "officially" saints of the Church. This from Pope Francis' homily at the canonisation Mass:
Jesus is radical. He gives all and he asks all: he gives a love that is total and asks for an undivided heart. Even today he gives himself to us as the living bread; can we give him crumbs in exchange? We cannot respond to him, who made himself our servant even going to the cross for us, only by observing some of the commandments. We cannot give him, who offers us eternal life, some odd moment of time. Jesus is not content with a “percentage of love”: we cannot love him twenty or fifty or sixty percent. It is either all or nothing.....
Today Jesus invites us to return to the source of joy, which is the encounter with him, the courageous choice to risk everything to follow him, the satisfaction of leaving something behind in order to embrace his way. The saints have travelled this path.
Paul VI did too, after the example of the Apostle whose name he took. Like him, Paul VI spent his life for Christ’s Gospel, crossing new boundaries and becoming its witness in proclamation and in dialogue, a prophet of a Church turned outwards, looking to those far away and taking care of the poor. Even in the midst of tiredness and misunderstanding, Paul VI bore witness in a passionate way to the beauty and the joy of following Christ totally. Today he still urges us, together with the Council whose wise helmsman he was, to live our common vocation: the universal call to holiness. Not to half measures, but to holiness. It is wonderful that together with him and the other new saints today, there is Archbishop Romero, who left the security of the world, even his own safety, in order to give his life according to the Gospel, close to the poor and to his people, with a heart drawn to Jesus and his brothers and sisters. We can say the same about Francesco Spinelli, Vincenzo Romano, Maria Caterina Kasper, Nazaria Ignazia of Saint Teresa of Jesus, and also our Abruzzese-Neapolitan young man, Nunzio Sulprizio: the saintly, courageous, humble young man who encountered Jesus in his suffering, in silence and in the offering of himself. All these saints, in different contexts, put today’s word into practice in their lives, without lukewarmness, without calculation, with the passion to risk everything and to leave it all behind. Brothers and sisters, may the Lord help us to imitate their example.  
Brief biographies of those canonised alongside Archbishop Romero and Pope Paul VI can be found here.

Friday, 21 September 2018

All the Cathedrals (10): St Albans

Zero and I visited St Albans recently, to tick off another of England's cathedrals.

The Cathedral website has a highlights page here. The story of the martyrdom of St Alban is here. Other aspects of the history of the Abbey/Cathedral can be found on links from those pages.

Visiting the Cathedral today, there is no readily visible evidence of the different vicissitudes that have been suffered by the building over the centuries. There is no evidence, at least not that we saw, of the Anglo-Saxon church or medieval church that might typically have existed before the construction of the Norman church (if I understand correctly, any such structures were not on the same site but nearby, and the construction of the Norman church was undertaken to take advantage of the top of the hill on which the Cathedral now exists). Neither is there any evidence (unless you look closely, and then there are only clues arising from the later restoration of the Cathedral) of the destruction and decay of the Church building that occurred after the dissolution of the monastery by Henry VIII's commissioner. All the statues in the Cathedral today, for example, date from 19th and 20th century restoration work, as does the stained glass. St Albans changed hands several times during the Civil War, with Parliament finally holding it. The Cathedral was then used to hold prisoners of war, the consequent damage from which is also no longer evident.

The Cathedral does have some lovely elements, such as the reredos behind the high altar and the Lady Chapel behind the sanctuary at the east end.




There are also the statues of Christian martyrs in the reredos behind the nave altar. St Alban and the priest who he protected are accompanied, among others, by Dietrich Bonhoeffer, Oscar Romero and one of the Protestant martyrs who suffered during the reign of Mary. This does not leave a uniformly satisfactory impression - I could not quite decide whether I should recognise it as genuine effort at ecumenical understanding or a manifestation, with the best of intentions, of a degree of religious indifferentism. One might also wonder about it as an example of cultural appropriation in a religious context ….


I also found that the building as a whole left an incoherent impression. Individual elements just seemed to exist with no relation to others - mediaeval wall paintings on the pillars on one side of the nave with decorated pillars on the opposite side that replaced previously collapsed pillars, but with no effort to match the two sides at all. Plaster over Roman brick in the transepts reflects the original construction of the Cathedral, but does not convey any majesty.

All in all, given that it is a Church dedicated to the first Christian martyr of England (and the restored shrine does contain a relic of St Alban) I found it a disappointment.

Sunday, 9 September 2018

Auntie Joanna's Adoremus Diary: a glorious celebration of the Eucharist

Read here.
More? Of course there was more. A pleasant meal with family and friends. Nightfever at the Blessed Sacrament shrine, packed with people, glittering with candles. Liverpool streets filled with Saturday night revellers, girls on hen nights, much shrieking and shouting. And some of them – many of them, the most unlikely of them – came in to pray, invited by the young congress teams.
As I post, the Eucharist is being carried in procession through the streets of Liverpool.

Saturday, 8 September 2018

Adoration may seem useless....

...but the world needs it desperately.

I link to this article in connection with the National Eucharistic Congress and Pilgrimage taking place in Liverpool today.

Coverage, with video clips that you can watch, here: https://www.shalomworldtv.org/adoremus

Friday, 7 September 2018

Adoremus: National Eucharistic Congress and Pilgrimage

This coming weekend sees the National Eucharistic Congress for England and Wales, being held in Liverpool: Adoremus.

Coverage of the Congress can be found here: http://www.shalomworldtv.org/adoremus.

You can also watch it on the homepages of these websites:
 

LIVE Broadcast dates and time as below,
 
FRIDAY, 7th September
10:00AM to 2:00PM
 
SATURDAY, 8th September
10:00AM to 2:00PM
 
SUNDAY, 9th September
11:00AM to 1:00PM
 

The Eucharistic procession through the streets of Liverpool on Sunday will remind me of my own participation in similar processions (I often happen to be away on holiday at the time of the Solemnity of Corpus Christi, so get the opportunity to participate in processions  in different places):

International Eucharistic Congress 2008 in Quebec.

The parish of Rivotorto, near to Assisi (twice).

Lisieux, at the Basilica dedicated to St Therese.

Bellano, on Lake Como.