Thursday, 30 April 2009

Is there such a thing as a vocation to "single life"?

My views on this question have always been strongly coloured by a book, originally published in German in 1955 and then in English translation in 1979, by Adrienne von Speyr. The book is called They followed His Call: Vocation and Asceticism. This was followed by a kind of intuitive antipathy to the suggestion that single life was a vocation equivalent in type to those of marriage, religious life or priesthood - the fashion for this in some contemporary pastoral activity in favour of a "culture of vocation" has always seemed to me to be a bit of a "let's not have anyone feel left out" syndrome without a substantial theological support. The accounts here and here, for example, appear rather unconvincing, and I am not sure I could find anything specifically single about the account here.

One aspect to this question is that of the age at which one responds to a call to a particular vocation. Perhaps for good reason, there has been a trend to accepting people into religious formation at an older age than in the past. Entering formation at an early age does clearly have the risk that such entry is seen as definitive, and those who find that they should leave and test a different vocation find it difficult to do so. But, on the other hand, if entry is left until later an opposite risk occurs. An older person can be more set in their ways, and therefore less docile and less adaptable to the formative demands of a particular form of life. I found this post at Southwark Vocations interesting, and would be supportive of its implication that we should perhaps be open to encouraging a response to vocation at an earlier age.

This question of the age at which one responds to a vocation is linked to that of how we understand the single state in the life of the Church. I happen to think that the single state, precisely as a single state (but see comments below about lay movements and ecclesial communities), is not a vocational choice in itself, and should not be presented as such in pastoral activity. It represents an openess towards a choice of vocation in the Church. So the situation of someone who remains single until late in life has something unfinished about it, something anomalous. This what Adrienne von Speyr writes about this:

The call reaches persons in their youth, and also older persons. But the "late called" are mostly those with whom the Lord's patience has persevered for so long that they have at last heard. If he closely examines his life, such a person will see that he owes his vocation to God's long suffering.

There is the possibility that the one who has remained single has done so because they have pushed the voice of the Lord calling them into the background, and hidden it away. They have, in effect, declined to answer their calling to a particular vocation. Adrienne von Speyr again:

The muting of the voice is such a frightening event and it so unsettles the person that whoever has said No or tried to put God off, postponing a decision, is a permanently marked man. He is and remains recognisable. He has pushed aside the experience of his life. In the future he remains embittered, dissatisfied, sarcastic and fault finding, and he never grows tired of ... trying to prove the impossibility of discipleship.... The No impresses itself and remains, and it is at times more capable of transforming a person's spiritual physiognomy more deeply that the Yes would have done.

Three of the chapters in Adrienne von Speyr's book are devoted in turn to the evangelical counsels of poverty, chastity and obedience. Writing in 1948 (so far as I can tell), Hans Urs von Balthasar began to present the life of the counsels as appropriate to the lay state of life in the Church. A work that he then originally entitled The Laity and the Religious State was later re-edited and published with the title The Laity and the Life of the Counsels. For both Adrienne von Speyr and Hans Urs von Balthasar, the form of the evangelical counsels, whether expressed in promises or in vows (private or public), is available to the lay person and represents the form of the Yes to the vocation from the Lord. An Apostolic Constitution of 1947, Provida Mater, gave lay associations in the Church the chance to achieve a canonical status as secular institutes. Hans Urs von Balthasar saw this as a great opportunity for the lay person - the secular institutes were a possibility open to the single lay person whose status in the Church otherwise remained anomalous. Writing of the potential of the lay person living the life of the counsels, Hans Urs von Balthasar says:

... the layman would never need to fear being unfaithful to his spiritual mission even in the most worldly turmoil of his professional work. For he would not have chosen this mission for himself; it would have been entrusted to him in the obedience of the counsels, and he would carry out under obedience all that it entails, even what appeared its most worldly dimension ....

It is scarcely possible to gauge a priori the springs of supernatural power that would be unleashed in such a life. Working in the same practice, office, or factory, but freed from the absorbing and often depressing concerns about family and earnings, the layman in the state of the counsels would have an incomparable advantage in terms of time, freedom, and productivity, not to mention the possibilities of taking up deeper questions that may not be immediately lucrative but are much more necessary, when seen with Christian eyes: public questions for which those with such busy private lives have no time, questions affecting the Church in the civil sphere, in which married people, who are dependent in so many ways, perhaps do ot want to take the risk of getting their fingers burned, questions of the apostolate in the lay milieu, which the priest finds impossible or at least difficult to approach ...

It is the spiritual value and significance for lay people of a life of the counsels that Hans Urs von Balthasar goes on to draw out, not just the practical possibilities of the single state. The future tense implicit in Hans Urs von Balthasar's words seems strange to us now, who so much take for granted the existence of lay movements and ecclesial communities in the Church. I have found it quite fascinating to see a kind of prophetic wisdom in the position of Adrienne von Speyr and Hans Urs von Balthasar, and it lies in this. Many of the new movements and ecclesial communities have, gradually, evolved a core group at the centre of their life who choose to live the life of the counsels. This is true of Communion and Liberation and of the Focolare, to name but two.

I would want to argue that the single state in the Church is not a vocational state in itself. It is full of opportunities to respond with a Yes to a vocation in the Church, the movements, ecclesial communities and secular institutes providing forms for that Yes in the single, lay state. Or, of course, it provides an openess to a vocation to the priesthood, religious life or marriage.

So, what of the person who reaches their later, or slightly later, years (or, to use a phrase now not often heard - the person who reaches their "middle youth") and is still single? Personally, I find the suggestion that being single in some way constitutes a vocation in itself patronising; it assumes a Yes that is not there in lived experience, and to try and pretend that it is there is unreal and, in the end, unhelpful. I suspect that it is possible that one is called to live, for a long period of time, in an openess towards a call that will only be revealed later in life; but that involves the radicalness of a living obedience, from one moment to the next moment, day in and day out, without the external scaffolding of formal commitment, that is a rare and quite exceptional, spiritual gift. One can also find a call to engagement in one or more particular activities on behalf of the Church or of the Christian mission in the world; but these engagements, providentially good and genuinely charismatic as they may be, remain a "secondary mission" that the Lord "tolerates". They cannot replace the "first" call that is pushed into the background in a refusal, a No.

UPDATE: This is a post that makes a couple of relevant points .... in its references to a person's "inability to commit to anything" at a certain age (!) and in its suggestion of inviting the girl out anyway instead of making an excuse ....

Tuesday, 28 April 2009

Bloggers on television

Those who were particularly sharp eyed will have seen this post - briefly - when I posted it a day or two ago before I pulled it for further editing. I have not really had the time to give it the further editing, but have received a comment from one of the sharp eyed about some of the advice it gave being helpful. So, in the spirit of offering something of help to others, I am putting it back up again now with one or two subsequent additions.

It has been interesting to notice that two Catholics appearing on television programmes have recently appeared with the straplines "Catholic bloggers". Being a blogger has become part of an identity group. I am thinking of James Preece and Joanna Bogle. And this post prompts thoughts on whether blogworthiness has now become newsworthiness.

One must give all due credit to those who agree to appear on television (or radio) to defend Pope Benedict XVI, and the teaching of the Church. It takes very considerable courage and nerve, so congratulations to them.

There is something in the view that those employed as media professionals by the Church - or, indeed, bishops themselves - should be willing to do this. In some situations this is probably true; but the hostility of the environment of a particular programme or interview can also lead to a legitimate judgement that that is not an environment in which the Church's view can be fairly or effectively communicated and so a declining of the invitation. There can be quite careful judgements to be made.

Looking at the number of comments attracted by James Preece's post linked above, I am reminded of the sheer power of television as a medium for getting a message into peoples lives. I am also reminded that a television appearance demands very different skills than posting to a blog. Only in the rarest situations is a television appearance an opportunity to present a reasoned, argued case. It is much more about "coming over well" and creating an "impression". Integrity demands that this is not done in a dishonest way; but, nevertheless, the exercise is not one of presenting a complete intellectual argument. In the jargon, it is about getting the sound bites correct.

In the past, partly through my trade union background but also from other sources, I have had the benefit of some training for news media. Herewith some thoughts:

1. It is always much more effective to present a positive case of your own rather than to be responding to an attack from the "other side". So you do not have to answer a point that is put to you in an interview - it can be much better to instead make a positive point of your own instead.

2. Decide what you want to say before you appear, and, write yourself a little script beforehand. A series of short, coherent points is what is needed - sound bites. I am inclined to use cards, one card for each point. And, see point 1, make them positive points. There might be some predictable points you can prepare because you know they are likely to come up, too; it is perhaps more important than ever to have a pre-prepared script for these. But try to make it positive, not a "reaction" answer.

3. And perhaps think of your appearance as an opportunity for evangelisation. Not to be forced unrealistically onto the interview/programme - that would be utterly counter-productive, but there might be a cue to allow a little sound bite of "primary proclamation".

4. Do not let yourself be forced to say something that you do not want to say. If in doubt, keep silent - silence is the interviewers problem, not yours, particularly in a one-to-one situation. Or, just pick one of your positive points and respond with that instead.

5. Remember, your reason for being there, as is true of everyone else who is appearing alongside you, even if they do not admit it, is NOT to answer questions that you might be asked. It is to communicate the message that you want to get over ...

So, Pope Benedict XVI is not a liability because:


how many people, predominantly young people, attended the closing Mass of the World Youth Day in Cologne in 2005? 1.2 million

what was the title of Pope Benedict's first encyclical letter? "God is Love". And let me read you a sentence or two of it (as I post this, I had reason to re-read a couple of paragraphs last night, and it really is quite something!)

As far as homosexuality is concerned? What do we mean by love? It's wanting the best thing for the other person, and what Pope Benedict is saying is that this is more than just what we might want to do, or are attracted towards (applies just as much to those who identify themselves as straight as to those who identify themselves as gay).

As far as others being "hurt" by Pope Benedict's teaching? The Church calls everyone to conversion, to change of life so as to be more like Christ. Everyone, not just those who identify themselves as gay - and it is uncomfortable and challenging, and affects different people in different areas of their lives. But we would expect Pope Benedict to offer that challenge to conversion.

Grass roots Catholics do not agree with the Pope? Well, many ordinary Catholics do agree with him - cf the numbers at World Youth Day, etc.

Which country is the first carbon neutral country in the world? Vatican City State (according to BBC radio news coverage this morning of Prince Charles visit to Pope Benedict)

Monday, 27 April 2009

Christian teacher suspended by school

The Christian Legal Centre are reporting the case of a Christian teacher who has been suspended after raising objections to an equal opportunities training session that turned into a deliberate promotion of homosexual and lesbian life styles. The report can be found here, and there are links at the bottom of the report to other electronic media coverage.

My trade union experience teaches me to be careful - very careful - of the "... and ..." when reading a report like this. The grounds for the allegations against Kwabena Peat lie in the letter that he wrote to his colleagues, and the contents of that letter remain essentially undisclosed. One can perhaps see - in the suggestions that Mr Peat referred to Biblical teaching in his letter - some seeds of justification for an allegation, seeds that might have been avoided with care. The idea of "writing privately" to his colleagues, rather than pursuing a complaint in a more formal (though "informal" in the procedural) sense also seems a little unwise. But the media reporting does not really make completely clear what has happened.

However, two things spring to mind.

1. The evidence itself seems quite clear cut - it is the text of a letter, and there seems to be little dispute about the contents or authorship of the letter. It strikes me that investigatory meetings and a hearing should not have necessarily taken as long as they appear to have done. Unless, of course, we are now nearing the end of a process of hearings and appeals. But one is left wondering whether a different undercurrent exists along with substance of the allegations themselves and the investigation of them.

2. Whatever the rights and wrongs of Mr Peat's conduct, the conduct of the trainer from Schools Out appears to have been utterly outrageous. As it has been reported, she showed a quite complete lack of respect for others who held a different view than her own, and appears to have done this on a very public platform. The word "equality" in the strapline of Schools Out, and other similar organisations, does need to be treated with a pinch of salt ....

Saturday, 25 April 2009

The Good, the Bad and the Ugly

The Times has today carried a feature entitled "The Pope's first four years have brought a fine crop of surprises and controversies". It allowed "five Roman Catholic observers [to] give their verdicts on the papacy of Pope Bendict XVI, so far". The electronic version misses out the contribution from John Allen, which appeared in the print edition, and which was the longest of the contributions.

More than one contributor suggested a need for a rather better PR machine at the Vatican so that some of the media controversies - not justified by the substance of Pope Benedict's remarks or actions - could be avoided.

The Good: John Allen, jr.
The spirit of Benedict's papacy can best be expressed by the phrase "affirmative orthodoxy"...

While Benedict XVI obviously sees secularism and relativism as enemies of the faith, for the most part he has chosen to do battle not with the weapons of anathema and excoriation, but by attempting to reintroduce Christianity as a positive cultural alternative.

In that spirit, devotees of papal pronouncements - not just the high profile examples, but the Pope's routine teaching during his Wednesday general audiences, his Sunday addresses, and so on - say that if you close your eyes when Benedict is on stage, and forget who is speaking, you could easily believe you are listening to one fo the great Fathers of the Church ... Benedict's material is almost always inspiring, spiritually rich, and rhetorically well crafted, leading some analysts to declare him one of the greatest "teaching popes" in Church history.

The Bad: Luke Coppen
It's tempting to judge the first four years of Benedict XVI's papacy entirely in terms of his tortured relationship with the Western media. But I suspect that in 100 years that will only be a historical footnote.

O, alright, I'll let Luke get away with that as a good point. But not this:
His key decisions - the liberation of the traditional Mass, the lifting of the SSPX excommunications - are fiercely misunderstood today, but look ahead ...

Summorum Pontificum and the accompanying letter to bishops made it juridically easier to celebrate Mass in the extraordinary form than before, but "liberation" is not really an accurate word to describe that. And, post Summorum Pontificum, it is not legitimate, from a juridical point of view, to talk about one form of the Roman Rite as being any more or any less traditional than the other. And, indeed, according the the accompanying letter, it is the Missal of Pope Paul VI that is envisaged as uniting parish communities. The misunderstanding occurs from both directions ...

The Ugly: Sir Stephen Wall
His theological pronouncements have been inaccessible, his comments on other faiths provocative, and his views on sexual morality a mixture of the extreme and bizarre.

One of the things about Pope Benedict's theological pronouncements is precisely that they are so accessible! And, in the wake of the Regensburg address, for example, the level and extent of Catholic-Islamic dialogue has been quite unprecedented.

Don't let Cormac accept a peerage

Memo to Rome - Don't let Cormac Accept a Peerage.

And this in the Guardian.

And there must be more around the interweb ...

Friday, 24 April 2009

St Edward's Catholic Church: Forty Hours 2009

This has been creeping up on me in the last week or so. The poster has been ready for a week or so, and I think I now have the programme finalised. If you are within reach, please drop in! Looking back through my files (electronic, of course), I see that this is now the sixth consecutive year that I have organised this event in my parish. The themes for each of the three days are based on the writings of St Paul on the Eucharist.



Thursday 7th May 2009
“We, though many, are one body, for we all partake of the one loaf” [1 Corinthians 10:17]

8.00 pm Solemn Votive Mass of the Holy Eucharist, followed by Adoration
10.00 pm Mothers Prayers, followed at 10.30 pm by Night Prayer
Adoration continues through the night.


Friday 8th May 2009
“This is my body that is for you .. This cup is the new covenant in my blood” [1 Cor.:11:24, 25]

Adoration all day

8.30 am Morning Prayer

6.30 pm - 7.00 pm Adoration for Children and Families (led by the Community of St John)

7.30 pm Mass: Votive Mass of the Precious Blood, followed by Holy Hour (ending at 9 pm)

Adoration continues until 10 pm

Saturday 9th May 2009
“As often as you eat this bread and drink the cup, you proclaim the death of the Lord until he comes” [1 Cor.:11:26]

Adoration from 6 am

9 am Votive Mass of Our Lady of the Cenacle (followed by Morning Prayer)

11-12 noon Sacrament of Reconciliation (Confession)

12.00 noon Regina Caeli and Rosary Hour

3 - 4 pm Prayer for the intentions of donors and those who have helped in any way with the days of adoration

4.30 - 5 pm Closing Adoration - Evening Prayer I of Sunday